Now that the American election is over, there has certainly been a dearth of juicy political happenings this side of the 49th. So if you are looking for some interesting political maneuvering, I direct your attention to America’s northern neighbor, where Canada’s usually dull political scene is shaking up.
First, a little background for those who are not familiar with Canadian politics:
Canada has a parliamentary system. This means that voters choose a member of parliament (MP) to represent their district in parliament. The party that has the most seats in parliament becomes the ruling party, and its leader becomes the prime minister. If the ruling party has over 50% of the seats, it is said to be a majority government – it can get its bills passed easily because it represent most of the parliament’s votes. If the ruling party has less than 50% of the seats, it forms a minority government. In a minority government, if any of the ruling party’s proposals get defeated, an election is immediately called by the Governor General (the GG is the Queen’s appointed representative, and is the official head of state in Canada, although her duties are largely ceremonial).
The Prime Minister can also ask the Governor General to call an election at any time. This year’s election was called by Prime Minister Stephen Harper because he thought his party (the Conservatives) had enough support to create a majority government. He was wrong. Although his party won the election, they could only form a minority government. This is where things get interesting…
Last week, Stephen Harper proposed his financial plan to guide the country through this global crisis. But in his plan, he also took the opportunity to throw in some very unpopular extras. The biggest of which was a provision that cuts all government funding for political parties – an act that would have essentially bankrupted every party except his own. Now, the other three parties took exception to this potentially devastating provision and formed a coalition to defeat the bill. Normally, this would simply cause the Governor General to call a new election (the second in three months!), but things got a little more complicated this time around.
In an unprecedented move, the three opposition parties have worked out a deal in which they would form a “coalition government,” instead of sending the country back to the polls. A Coalition Government? Even if it is constitutional to set up a new government from an existing parliament (scholars are split on the issue), there hasn’t been a coalition government in Canada for over 91 years, and I’m not surprised – getting Canada’s parties to agree on things is difficult during the best of times, what will happen when they have to share executive power? According the plan, this coalition government would appoint Liberal Leader Stephane Dion as Prime Minister, and appoint cabinet ministers from both the Liberal and the NDP Parties. The biggest problem with this is that Stephane Dion completely botched this fall’s election, and is extremely unpopular. The Liberal Party is planning on electing a new leader at their convention in May, and is in the middle of a heated leadership race. Presumably, the new Liberal leader would take over as Prime Minister next May.
What a crazy mess Ottawa has gotten itself into! Is Canada going to have another election three months after its last? Will there really be a coalition government? Even if you like the Liberal Party, you have to be concerned that the coalition government will be beholding to the “separatists and the socialists.” And do we really want Stephane Dion leading our country during these difficult financial times – a man who has shown himself to be a quite ineffectual leader? The only thing I can say for sure is that Stephen Harper was some kind of stupid for using the financial crisis to further his own political interests in such a blatant manner – and when he’s got a minority government to boot!
I’m really interested to see how this shakes out. I think that maybe there should be another election – see what the people thinks about Harper’s antics. Or else maybe try and work out a compromise solution until the Liberals can get their whole leadership situation cleared up. But who knows – now that the opposition parties have caught a glimpse of power, they seem determined to take it all the way to the end-zone. Stay tuned and I’ll try and keep you all updated.
Filed under: Canadian Politics


From reactions around here, regardless if you like or hate Stephen Harper, I don’t think people want to go back to the polls. But I don’t know about the coalition government either.
I personally wish the government would stop their fighting, and get to running this country.
“What a tangled web we weave when at first we try…..” and bankrupt your opposition.
This is a comedy of errors, Stephen for misplaying his cards and the Liberals, the socialists and the separatists for thinking Canadians wants them to rescue us. Stephen should stop being a bully and the others acting like children and taking their ball and going home. They’re all mavericks.
I just wanted to note your title, “What the heck are those crazy canucks doing up there?” Sounds like you’ve removed yourself from any affiliation to your home country.
Although I will join you on the sentiment, what the heck is our government doing?
I can see why my title would give off that impression – but rest assured that I have not removed myself from my home country (I just thought the title sounded cool)
Two major issues here:
1. “Scholars are split on this issue”?!?!? Are you on crack?!? Coalition government is actually pretty much just what the constitution implies! Political parties are entirely absent from the Canadian constitution, so how could it be unconstitutional for a majority of parliament to join forces and form a government? If the Cons lose a confidence vote and there’s a coalition willing to take over it’s entirely up to the GG to decide if they’ll be capable of forming a stable government. If she thinks they can, that’s it, end of story. Not only Constitutional, but exactly what the Westminster system is designed to create: Collaborating elected representatives deciding policy for the people who voted for them.
Don’t believe me? Check this out: http://ulsu.wordpress.com/2008/12/02/the-liberals-ndp-and-bloc-are-trying-to-steal-the-government-source-most-canadian-headlines-over-the-last-couple-of-days/
2. The NDP are NOT socialists. I don’t get how this title got pushed onto them in the first place. If it’s a campaign tactic to try and scare people away from voting for them by painting them with a brush that doesn’t suit them, I don’t think it’s a wise one. I’m pretty sure Canadians aren’t that stupid. After all, even Americans weren’t that stupid; just ask John McCain.
Having said all that, it’s good to see that not all Conservative supporters are so ignorant that you don’t see that Harper’s being stupid. I mean: “an act that would have essentially bankrupted every party except his own” ! It’s totally true, but all the crap flying around on Conservative blogs and networking groups almost convinced me that you all believed the propaganda Harper’s spewing!
Way to have some integrity. And a brain.
Just a quick response to Russ, in order to defend my honor:
1. You may be right about the constitutionality of the coalition – I think I got that “scholars are split on the issue” line from something I read, and I could have misinterpreted it.
2. Didn’t you notice that I put the phrase “separatists and socialists” in quotation marks, which I think is a pretty clear indication that I was simply using the phrase that is being thrown around, without actually adopting it myself.
3. I am insulted that you automatically think I am a Conservative Supporter because I am not convinced the coalition is a good idea. I thought my piece was rather neutral (After all, I called DIon “an ineffectual leader,” but I called Harper “some kind of stupid,” which I think is a little bit worse).
I thought “crazy canucks” was referring to that picture of yourself in the banner at the top of your site… you’ve totally captured the crazy canuck look…
craigthegrey, I love your comment. I’ve been trying to figure out something to say about that photo and i think you nailed it.